A federal judge has dismissed the majority of claims in a civil lawsuit filed against the Coconino County Detention Facility and its command staff for the 2022 death of Gibson Benally.
In response, attorneys for Benally’s daughter submitted an amended complaint last Friday, April 25, restating their allegations against all the original targets of the suit.
kAm}6:E96C E96 ;F586 ?@C E96 5676?52?ED 92G6 J6E C6DA@?565 E@ E9@D6 ?6H=J C6G:D65 244FD2E:@?D] %96 pC:K@?2 s2:=J $F? C624965 @FE E@ E96 r@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ $96C:77’D ~77:46 2D H6== 2D E@ 2EE@C?6JD 7@C E96 A=2:?E:77 2?5 5676?52?ED] pE E96 E:>6 @7 AF3=:42E:@?[ ?@?6 @7 E96 A2CE:6D 925 AC@G:565 2?J 4@>>6?E]k^Am
kAmq6?2==J[ H9@ H2D db[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2K52:=JDF?]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^244:56?E\2?5\:?4:56?E^:?>2E6\5:6D\@7\DFDA64E65\>65:42=\6>6C86?4J\:?\4@4@?:?@\4@F?EJ\;2:=^2CE:4=603ae6dd2_\4_57\``64\3dbb\afadb6_c47dg]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm5:65 H9:=6 :? 4FDE@5Jk^2m @? pAC:= `g[ a_aa] sFC:?8 9:D :?42C46C2E:@? 2E E96 r@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ s6E6?E:@? u24:=:EJ[ 96 C646:G65 9:D AC6D4C:365 3=@@5 AC6DDFC6 >65:42E:@? @?=J “DA@C25:42==J[� 244@C5:?8 E@ 4@FCE 5@4F>6?ED[ 2?5 6IA6C:6?465 D9@CE?6DD @7 3C62E9 2?5 5:KK:?6DD 7@C 2AAC@I:>2E6=J ac 9@FCD 367@C6 9:D 562E9] p? 2FE@ADJ F=E:>2E6=J 56E6C>:?65 E96 42FD6 @7 562E9 H2D AF=>@?2CJ E9C@>3@6>3@=:D> \\ 2 3=@@5 4=@E 3=@4<:?8 @?6 @7 E96 2CE6C:6D E@ 9:D =F?8D]k^Am
kAmx? |2C49 a_ac[ q6?2==J’D 72>:=J >6>36CD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2K52:=JDF?]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^7656C2=\=2HDF:E\7:=65\282:?DE\4@4@?:?@\4@F?EJ\;2:=\:?\a_aa\562E9\@7\8:3D@?\36?2==J^2CE:4=60_4632_fa\75hb\``66\g52f\_7d_b4hah5b3]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmDF65k^2m r@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ 2?5 }2G2;@ r@F?EJ \\ H96C6 q6?2==J H2D @C:8:?2==J 96=5 :? 4FDE@5J 367@C6 9:D EC2?D76C E@ E96 u=28DE277 724:=:EJ \\ 2=@?8 H:E9 4@>>2?5 DE277 @7 3@E9 4@F?E:6D� D96C:77’D @77:46D[ 2?5 :?5:G:5F2= 962=E942C6 AC24E:E:@?6CD H9@ :?E6C24E65 H:E9 q6?2==J :? E96 ;2:=D]k^Am
kAm%96 DF:E 2==6865 HC@?87F= 562E9 2D 2 C6DF=E @7 56?:2= @7 256BF2E6 >65:42= 42C6]k^Am
kAmyF586 |:4926= {:3FC5: @7 E96 &]$] s:DEC:4E r@FCE 7@C pC:K@?2 CF=65 @? |2C49 `f E92E E96 4@F?E:6D 2?5 4@F?EJ @77:4:2=D ?2>65 :? E96 DF:E \\ :?4=F5:?8 E96 D96C:77D 2?5 49:67 56AFE:6D @7 3@E9 4@F?E:6D \\ 4@F=5 ?@E 36 96=5 =:23=6 :? E96 42D6] %96 A=2:?E:77D[ {:3FC5: HC@E6[ 925 72:=65 E@ AC@G6 E92E q6?2==J’D 562E9 H2D 2 C6DF=E @7 2 4@F?EJ “A@=:4J[ 4FDE@> @C AC24E:46[� @C E@ AC@G6 2 �42FD2= 4@??64E:@?� 36EH66? 4@>>2?5 DE277’D 24E:@?D 2?5 E96 562E9]k^Am
kAmp44@C5:?8=J[ 96 5:D>:DD65 E96 4=2:>D 282:?DE 2== @7 E9@D6 5676?52?ED[ D:8?:7:42?E=J ?2CC@H:?8 E96 D4@A6 @7 E96 =2HDF:E] qFE 96 5:5 D@ QH:E9@FE AC6;F5:46[Q =62G:?8 @A6? E96 A@DD:3:=:EJ E96 A=2:?E:77D 4@F=5 3C:?8 D:>:=2C @C C6G:D65 4=2:>D :? E96 7FEFC6]k^Am
kAm{:3FC5: 2=D@ CF=65 E92E E96 DA64:7:4 2==682E:@?D 282:?DE EH@ :?5:G:5F2= 5676?52?ED \\ {62?? y2>6D 2?5 y2?66? uC2D6C[ 3@E9 H@C<:?8 2D ?FCD6D :? E96 r@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ ;2:= 2E E96 E:>6 @7 q6?2==J’D 562E9 \\ H6C6 DF77:4:6?E E@ 2==@H 4=2:>D 282:?DE E96> E@ AC@4665] %96 DF:E 244FD65 E96> @7 G:@=2E:?8 q6?2==J’D :?5:G:5F2= C:89ED 3J 72:=:?8 E@ AC@G:56 256BF2E6 >65:42= 42C6 2D C6BF:C65 3J =2H]k^Am
kAm~? pAC:= ad[ 2EE@C?6JD 7@C v:3D@? q6?2==J’D 52F89E6C #6?2=52 q6?2==J 7:=65 2 >@E:@? E@ :?EC@5F46 2 $64@?5 p>6?565 r@>A=2:?E[ @?46 282:? 244FD:?8 2== E96 @C:8:?2= 5676?52?ED @7 G:@=2E:?8 v:3D@? q6?2==J’D 4:G:= C:89ED 2?5 42FD:?8 9:D 562E9]k^Am
kAmx? E92E 7:=:?8[ :?E6?565 E@ 255C6DD E96 â€�567:4:6?4:6Dâ€� :56?E:7:65 3J {:3FC5:[ E96J 2==686 E92E E96 A@=:4:6D 2?5 4FDE@>D @7 3@E9 ;2:=D â€�6>A92D:K65 4@DE 4@?E2:?>6?E[ 5:D4@FC2865 @FED:56 >65:42= C676CC2=D 2?5 A6C>:EE65 4@CC64E:@?2= DE277 E@ @G6CC:56 >65:42= ;F58>6?E]â€k^Am
kAm%96J 2=D@ 2DD6CE E96 4@F?EJ ;2:=D �925 2 H:56DAC625 2?5 H6==\D6EE=65 4FDE@> @7 ?@E E:>6=J AC@G:5:?8 >65:42E:@?D E@ 56E2:?66D[ 6DA64:2==J @G6C H66<6?5D[� 2?5 �925 56 724E@ A@=:4:6D @7 F?56C\>@?:E@C:?8 D:4< 56E2:?66D 2?5 72:=:?8 E@ :?E6CG6?6 6G6? 27E6C 4=62C 56E6C:@C2E:@?]� %96 “DFA6CG:D@CJ 5676?52?ED[� :?4=F5:?8 E96 D96C:77D[ “C2E:7:65 E96 56?:2= @7 >65:42= 42C6 3J 72:=:?8 E@ 5:D4:A=:?6 @C C6EC2:? C6DA@?D:3=6 DE277[� E96 4@>A=2:?E 4=2:>D]k^Am
kAm%96 2>6?565 4@>A=2:?E D66<D 2 ;FCJ EC:2= 7@C E96 42D6] pD @7 |@?52JkDA2? 4=2DDlQAC:?E0EC:>Qm[ pAC:= ag[k^DA2?m {:3FC5: 925 ?@E J6E CF=65 @? H96E96C E96 >@5:7:65 G6CD:@? @7 E96 4@>A=2:?E H@F=5 36 2446AE65]k^Am
kAm#6?2=52 q6?2==J :D 36:?8 C6AC6D6?E65 3J E96 r9:428@\32D65 4:G:= C:89ED =2H 7:C> {@6GJ U2>Aj {@6GJ 2?5 u=28DE277\32D65 2EE@C?6J {66 !9:==:AD]k^Am
kAm“q6:?8 D6?E E@ ;2:= D9@F=5 ?@E 36 2 562E9 D6?E6?46[â€� D96 DE2E65 =2DE J62C H96? 96C =2HDF:E H2D AF3=:4=J 2??@F?465] “|J 72E96C D9@F=5 36 2=:G6 H:E9 FD E@52J]â€k^Am
kAm%96 4C:>:?2= 2==682E:@?D =625:?8 E@ v:3D@? q6?2==J’D :?42C46C2E:@? H6C6 J62CD @=5 3J E96 E:>6 @7 9:D 562E9] w6 H2D 2CC6DE65 @? 2 H2CC2?E 7@C 72:=FC6 E@ 2AA62C :? 4@FCE[ :DDF65 :? a_`g 3J r@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ $FA6C:@C r@FCE yF586 r2E9=66? q] }:49@=D] w6 925 @C:8:?2==J 366? 492C865 :? a_`f H:E9 EH@ 76=@?J 4@F?ED @7 5C:G:?8 F?56C E96 :?7=F6?46 H9:=6 9:D =:46?D6 H2D DFDA6?565 @C C6G@<65]k^Am
kAmr@4@?:?@ r@F?EJ :D 4FCC6?E=J A=2??:?8 2 >2;@C 6IA2?D:@? @7 :ED ;2:=’D >65:42= F?:E] {2DE >@?E9[ E96 q@2C5 @7 $FA6CG:D@CD 2AAC@G65 E96 :DDF2?46 @7 DA64:2=\@3=:82E:@? 3@?5D H@CE9 S`_ >:==:@? E@ AC@G:56 7F?5:?8 7@C E92E AC@;64E]k^Am